Mortgage Advisor on FIRE is taking a short break while I rework the site, with the first post of the refreshed blog aiming to go live on Sunday 29th November.
The subjects aren’t changing. There’ll still be finance, mental health, work, politics, science, fiction, and whatever else gets lodged in my brain that week. The weekly update is staying too.
What will change is the length. I want posts to be shorter and more focused, without feeling that every Sunday needs a 4,000-word epic. Hopefully, that will make them easier to read and give us more room for discussion.
I’m also considering some new sections, including revisiting basic financial lessons, and bringing the blog and the Autism and Financial Independence Podcast closer together.
After seven years, it feels like a good time for a refresh. Thanks for sticking with me, and if there’s something you’d like to see more of, let me know.
Finally, as I’ve been smashing through the Dungeon Crawler Carl series, here’s an image of me and Poppy hard at work….
In Episode 17 of the AFI podcast, I discuss the pros and cons of renting together before buying a property together. So often in my career as a mortgage advisor, I have seen people live together for the first time only when buying a home together, and it’s often an expensive mistake. In this episode, I offer an alternative.
Hello and welcome back to Mortgage Advisor on FIRE.
Weekly Update
It’s been a busy week of activities and work. On Wednesday evening, Oana and I were supposed to attend a talk about the Cost of Living Crisis at the University of Sheffield. However, there was heavy traffic, and our Uber was still fifteen minutes away from the venue five minutes after the start time. So, we changed the destination to an Indian restaurant and had a great meal instead.
On Thursday we took part in the Glow Ride, which happens up and down the country on the same night to promote better cycling infrastructure and improved safety, especially for women cyclists. It was a fun night, and by the end of Thursday Oana and I had cycled over 50km.
Friday evening we attended a tribute piano concert to Ludovico Einaudi, and went for a meal. It was another great night, although I found the venue a little uncomfortable.
We were supposed to have a day out in Sheffield for Out of this World on Sunday, but the weather had other plans.
The AFI Podcast
Check out the AFI section of this site for links to the pod on the various platforms.
As a new podcast, getting noticed is difficult, so please help us out by sharing the links and leaving a rating and review.
See below for a link to the latest episode where I break down the pros and cons of buying a house versus renting.
What I’m Doing
Listening: The Gate of the Feral Gods: Dungeon Crawler Carl Book 4 by Matt Dinniman.
Watching: The Diplomat (Netflix).
Reading: Abaddon’s Gate (Expanse Book 3) by James S. A. Corey.
I am loving the Dungeon Crawler Carl series. It’s rocketed up to a high spot on my favourite list of books. On the face of it, it’s a bit of a daft concept, but there are deeper themes and ideas running through it, and some truly fantastic character work. I’m thoroughly enjoying it and can’t wait for each time I pick up my headphones to listen.
Financial Update
Assets
Premium Bonds: £500.00.
Stocks and Shares ISA: £140,651.61.
Fuck It Fund: £0.00.
Pensions: £126,437.01.
Residential Property Value: £241,838.00.
Total Assets: £509,426.62.
Debts
Residential Mortgage: £173,115.21.
Total Debts: £173,115.21.
Total Wealth
Total Wealth: £336,311.41.
The quarterly update to the lender’s index valuations has taken place and our apartment value has dropped a few thousand. It’s not something that actually matters at this point, as it only has an impact if we need to do something with the mortgage like additional borrowing.
My investments are plodding along nicely without any sharp movement in either direction. Looking at my business pipeline, it looks as though early in the new year I should be able to start seriously investing again. I just need the conveyor belt to build up to full steam.
1. Simulation Theory: What If None of This Is Real?
And so we finally reach number one on the list of the most insane conspiracy theories I could think of.
We’ve had a flat Earth, a hollow Earth, phantom centuries, fake Moon landings, holographic gods, swapped ocean liners, and governments secretly blowing up skyscrapers. But for the top spot, I wanted something that makes all of those seem rather pedestrian.
What if none of this physically exists?
What if you aren’t actually sitting there reading this blog? What if I’m not really sitting at a computer writing it? What if Sheffield Wednesday, my mortgage, my bike, my cat and the balance of my investment portfolio are nothing more than information being processed by some unimaginably sophisticated computer?
Welcome to simulation theory.
And what makes this one particularly fascinating is that, unlike Flat Earth, I can’t spend the next 2,000 words explaining why it’s demonstrably bollocks.
Because it might actually be true.
Fuuuuuck…
Are we living in The Matrix?
The basic idea is beautifully simple.
Our perceived universe might be a simulation.
Everything we experience as physical reality, from the chair underneath you to the stars billions of light-years away, could ultimately be information being processed within some larger underlying reality.
You and I might therefore not exist in the way we intuitively think we do.
Our bodies could be simulated. Our planet could be simulated. The entire observable universe could be simulated.
The obvious comparison is The Matrix, although simulation theory doesn’t necessarily require us to be biological humans plugged into machines somewhere. We could exist entirely within the simulation. There might never have been a “real” David outside it.
Which raises the slightly uncomfortable possibility that somewhere, some alien teenager has left me running while they’ve gone downstairs for their dinner.
At least that would explain some of the decisions I’ve made, and it may also explain oddities like Trump and Boris Johnson, but that could just be malware.
The simulation argument
One of the most famous modern versions comes from philosopher Nick Bostrom, who published a paper in 2003 called Are You Living in a Computer Simulation?
Importantly, Bostrom didn’t simply argue:
“We’re definitely living in a simulation.”
His argument is more subtle.
Very roughly, he suggested that at least one of three propositions must be true.
First, almost all civilisations at our level of technological development become extinct before becoming capable of creating vast numbers of highly realistic simulations containing conscious beings.
Second, civilisations that do reach that technological level aren’t particularly interested in running large numbers of simulations of their ancestors.
Or third, we are almost certainly living in a simulation.
The logic behind the third possibility is where things get interesting.
Imagine humanity survives for another 10,000 years and develops computers powerful enough to simulate entire worlds containing billions of conscious people.
Suppose we create thousands, millions or billions of these simulated civilisations.
You would then have vastly more simulated people than original biological people.
If every simulated person experiences their world as completely real, and you were randomly selected from the total population of conscious observers, statistically you would be much more likely to be one of the simulated ones.
Imagine one original Earth containing eight billion people but one million simulated Earths, each containing another eight billion apparently conscious inhabitants.
Suddenly the odds of being on the original Earth aren’t looking fantastic.
It’s the philosophical equivalent of discovering there are a million identical Wetherspoons and being asked to prove you’re sitting in the original.
But could we actually simulate a universe?
Here’s the first enormous objection. We’re assuming such simulations are possible, but we don’t know that for certain. We can run sophisticated games like Civilization, The Sims, and MMORPGs, but this is still a far cry from simulating a whole universe.
Yes, computer games have become astonishingly sophisticated within a few decades, but there’s quite a gap between Pong and creating several billion genuinely conscious human beings who have absolutely no idea they’re software.
Increasing computing power doesn’t automatically mean we’ll eventually be capable of simulating consciousness, planets or entire universes.
There may be fundamental physical limits.
There is also an extraordinary amount of information in our universe. Simulating every particle and interaction at the most fundamental level might require computational resources comparable to, or even greater than, the universe being simulated.
Which would be a bit inconvenient.
But there’s another possibility.
Maybe you don’t need to simulate everything.
Does the universe only render what we’re looking at?
This is one of my favourite ideas because it makes reality sound suspiciously like a computer game desperately trying to maintain its frame rate.
Games don’t necessarily calculate every detail of their worlds continuously. They concentrate computational resources on whatever the player can interact with or observe.
The mountain visible in the distance doesn’t necessarily contain a fully simulated ecosystem with individual worms crawling through its soil.
It’s scenery until you get there. It’s like in some of the older GTA games where you cross a boundary, like a bridge, and the game pauses briefly to update the next neighbourhood.
Could a simulated universe work similarly?
Perhaps reality only needs to be calculated in sufficient detail when something interacts with it. Philosophers have touched on this before; if a tree falls in the woods, but no one is there, does it make a sound?
Quantum mechanics inevitably gets dragged into this conversation because particles at microscopic scales don’t behave anything like objects in our everyday experience. Quantum systems can exist in combinations of possible states, while measurement produces definite observable outcomes.
Some people interpret this as suspiciously similar to reality being “rendered” when observed.
It’s a wonderful idea. Unfortunately, it’s also an enormous leap.
Quantum mechanics is genuinely weird, but weird physics isn’t evidence of computer code. Physicists have mathematical frameworks that successfully predict quantum behaviour without needing an alien graphics card somewhere outside the universe.
Saying “quantum mechanics is strange, therefore we’re inside a computer” is basically the scientific equivalent of hearing something downstairs at night and immediately concluding it’s a Victorian ghost.
Interesting possibility but several steps missing such as actual evidence.
What about the speed of light?
Another popular argument is that the universe appears to have built-in limitations.
Nothing carrying information can simply accelerate beyond the speed of light in vacuum. There are smallest meaningful scales appearing in our physical theories. Energy comes in quantised amounts. Nature operates according to remarkably consistent mathematical laws.
That can make the universe feel suspiciously computational.
Maybe the speed of light is essentially the processing-speed limit. Maybe quantum properties are the universe’s resolution. Maybe physical laws are simply the source code.
It’s a seductive comparison because modern computers have made concepts like processing limits, pixels and information familiar to us, but there’s a problem…
We’re describing the universe using technology we invented inside the universe.
People living during the Industrial Revolution might have imagined the universe as an enormous machine full of gears. Today we imagine it as a computer.
In 500 years, humans might use some technology we can’t currently conceive and wonder why their ancestors were obsessed with comparing reality to primitive silicon processors.
Perhaps the universe doesn’t resemble a computer.
Perhaps computers resemble the universe because we built them using the same physical laws.
The suspiciously mathematical universe
This is where simulation theory becomes genuinely interesting.
Reality is extraordinarily describable through mathematics.
Relatively compact equations can describe gravity, electromagnetism and the behaviour of matter with astonishing accuracy. Mathematics invented or discovered through abstract reasoning sometimes turns out to describe physical phenomena extraordinarily well.
Why should the universe be so mathematically orderly?
One possible answer is simply that mathematics is the language humans developed to describe patterns in nature.
Another is that mathematical structure is somehow fundamental to reality.
And then simulation enthusiasts arrive through the wall shouting:
“BECAUSE IT’S CODE!”
Possibly, but again, we’re moving from interesting observation to specific explanation without enough evidence between the two.
A universe governed by mathematical regularities is exactly what we would expect if it were simulated.
Unfortunately, it’s also exactly what we observe in a universe that might not be simulated.
Hmmm…
What about fine-tuning?
Then we have the apparent fine-tuning of the universe.
Certain physical constants appear to fall within ranges compatible with complex structures and life. Change some of them sufficiently and stars, chemistry or stable matter as we know them may become impossible.
Why?
One explanation is that there are many universes with different physical properties and, unsurprisingly, conscious observers find themselves in one capable of producing conscious observers, i.e. the anthropic principle.
Someone configured the settings.
Perhaps we’re living in Universe_Experiment_8472_FINAL_v3.
Again, though, fine-tuning doesn’t demonstrate simulation. It simply creates a question for which simulation is one possible answer.
And there’s a recurring theme developing here.
Simulation theory is extremely good at saying, “Well, that would make sense if we’re simulated”, but not so much at saying, “Here’s something that could only happen if we’re simulated.”
What about glitches in the Matrix?
This is where a fascinating philosophical argument inevitably crashes into TikTok.
People report déjà vu, coincidences, objects apparently disappearing and reappearing, strange memories and events that seem impossible.
These are sometimes described as “glitches in the Matrix”.
I’ve already covered the Mandela Effect in this series, where large groups of people confidently remember things that apparently never happened.
Could these be evidence that someone altered the simulation?
Technically, I suppose, but there’s a slightly more mundane candidate explanation.
Human memory is absolutely terrible.
Our brains forget things, reconstruct memories, overlook objects sitting directly in front of us and find patterns in coincidences.
If my keys aren’t where I remember leaving them, there are two possibilities.
One: I misplaced my keys.
Two: the computer system generating physical reality temporarily failed to correctly load the key asset into my local environment.
I’m going with option one until further evidence emerges.
What if some people are NPCs?
Now we arrive at the point where simulation theory manages to become even more disturbing.
If we’re living inside a simulation, does everyone actually need to be conscious?
Video games are filled with non-player characters, or NPCs. They look like inhabitants of the game world and behave according to whatever rules have been programmed for them, but there’s nobody actually in there. The hotdog vendor in GTA isn’t experiencing an existential crisis while you’re off fighting the police. At least I hope not.
So if our reality were simulated, it’s tempting to ask whether the same principle could apply here. Perhaps only some inhabitants need genuine consciousness, while everyone else merely behaves convincingly enough to maintain the simulation.
This idea occasionally gets mixed up with the philosophical concept of a philosophical zombie: a hypothetical being physically and behaviourally indistinguishable from a conscious human but with no subjective experience whatsoever. It could laugh, cry, complain about the weather and spend twenty minutes telling you about the parking situation at Meadowhall, yet there would supposedly be no inner experience behind any of it.
Which immediately creates an absolutely enormous problem.
How the hell would you know?
I know that I’m conscious because I’m directly experiencing my own thoughts. I assume you’re conscious because you’re another human being with a brain broadly like mine who behaves as though you have thoughts and feelings too. That’s an extremely reasonable assumption, but I can’t climb inside your consciousness and verify it directly.
This is essentially the old philosophical problem of other minds, except simulation theory gives it a deeply irritating software update.
If this were a simulation designed to conserve computational resources, perhaps it wouldn’t need eight billion fully conscious minds. Maybe some people could essentially be incredibly sophisticated background characters, becoming more detailed only when another conscious observer interacts with them.
It’s an entertaining thought experiment, but there’s absolutely no good evidence that this is actually happening. And calling real people “NPCs” because they behave predictably, hold opinions we disagree with or seem to follow the crowd proves precisely nothing about whether they’re conscious. Human beings are social animals. We imitate each other, develop routines, follow fashions and occasionally stand in a queue without apparently knowing what the fucking queue is for. None of that requires computer programming.
There is also something slightly dangerous about taking the idea too seriously. If you convince yourself that certain people aren’t really conscious, it becomes much easier to treat them as though their experiences don’t matter. Whatever the ultimate nature of reality, the sensible assumption is that other people possess inner lives every bit as real and complicated as our own.
Still, as a philosophical question, it’s wonderfully creepy.
Perhaps everyone is conscious.
Perhaps only some of us are.
Perhaps I’m the NPC and you’re the player.
Or perhaps you’re currently reading a blog post written by an artificial intelligence about whether human beings are artificial intelligence inside an artificial universe.
At which point reality has disappeared so comprehensively up its own arse that I think we should probably move on.
The biggest problem: how would we ever know?
This is what earns simulation theory the number-one spot for me.
Imagine the simulation is perfect. Every scientific experiment we perform occurs inside it. Every telescope we build is simulated. Every particle accelerator is simulated.
Every measurement we take uses simulated equipment measuring simulated particles according to simulated physical laws.
How could we detect the outside world? It might be impossible.
Imagine a character in The Sims attempting to prove that your computer exists.
Everything available to them is contained within their world. They can’t dismantle their universe and discover your CPU because the CPU isn’t physically located anywhere inside their universe. Well, the same could apply to us.
We could search for irregularities, computational limits or apparent shortcuts in physical laws, but even finding something unusual wouldn’t necessarily demonstrate simulation.
That makes simulation theory extraordinarily difficult to falsify, and that’s a serious problem scientifically.
If no possible observation can establish that a claim is false, how do we meaningfully test it?
Then who simulated the simulators?
Here comes another headache.
Suppose tomorrow we somehow prove beyond reasonable doubt that our universe is simulated.
Fantastic, but who created it?
Perhaps an advanced civilisation in the “real” universe – Fine.
Where did their universe come from? Maybe they’re simulated too.
And their creators? Also simulated.
Congratulations. We’ve solved the mystery of reality by replacing it with an infinite tower of increasingly confused IT departments.
Eventually you either reach some underlying reality that isn’t simulated, or you have an infinite regress of simulations inside simulations.
And if a base reality exists, we’re immediately back to the original question.
Why does that reality exist?
Simulation theory therefore doesn’t necessarily solve the fundamental mystery of existence.
It’s just turtles all the way down.
Consciousness might ruin the whole thing
There’s another enormous assumption buried inside Bostrom’s argument.
Can consciousness actually be simulated?
We don’t even fully understand what consciousness is.
We know brains and conscious experience are intimately connected, but we don’t know whether sufficiently accurate computational reproduction of a brain would genuinely create subjective experience.
Would simulated David actually experience happiness, fear, pain and the soul-destroying experience of watching Sheffield Wednesday concede in stoppage time?
Or would simulated David merely behave as though he did?
From outside, those might look identical.
From my perspective, there’s a fairly fucking significant difference.
If consciousness cannot arise purely from computation, then the idea of vast populations of simulated conscious observers becomes much harder to sustain.
Until we understand consciousness better, this remains a gigantic unknown sitting underneath the whole argument.
So are we simulated?
I haven’t got a clue, and neither does anyone else.
That’s precisely why I find this one so much more interesting than most conspiracy theories.
Flat Earth can be tested and falsified. The Moon landings produced physical evidence.
Historical conspiracy claims can be checked against documents, archaeology and eyewitness testimony.
Simulation theory attacks the reliability of the entire framework we use to establish what is real.
Any evidence we discover could itself be simulated.
Even proving that our universe behaves computationally wouldn’t necessarily settle the matter because information and mathematics might simply be fundamental properties of ordinary reality.
Equally, failing to find evidence of simulation proves very little if the simulation is sufficiently sophisticated.
It’s almost perfectly constructed to mess with your head.
Does it actually matter?
Here’s perhaps the most important question.
Suppose we’re simulated.
So what?
If my experiences feel real to me, does it matter whether the underlying substrate is biological matter, quantum fields or the 94-billionth save file on some extraterrestrial laptop?
Pain still hurts. Love still matters. People still die.
Actions still have consequences within the reality we experience.
My mortgage lender certainly isn’t going to accept:
“I have stopped making payments because I’ve concluded that property ownership is merely an emergent phenomenon within a computational substrate.”
They’ll still repossess my simulated flat, but there might be a note added to the system about my obvious cognitive impairment.
Financial independence would still matter too. Even if money consists of imaginary numbers stored inside an artificial universe, that’s barely different from the current arrangement.
Perhaps the strangest conclusion is that discovering we’re simulated wouldn’t necessarily make our lives meaningless.
We would still exist in some sense. We think, experience and interact.
The nature of the machinery underneath that experience might simply be different from what we assumed.
Why it’s my number one
Most of the theories in this list require us to ignore mountains of evidence.
Simulation theory is different. It doesn’t have compelling evidence for it, but it’s extraordinarily difficult to produce decisive evidence against it.
That’s why it deserves the top spot. Not because I think we’re living in a simulation. I have no particular reason to believe we are, but because the possibility is completely fucking insane while remaining annoyingly difficult to dismiss entirely.
We might live in an ordinary physical universe. We might exist inside an ancestral simulation created by our descendants.
We might be an experiment run by an intelligence so advanced that we’d struggle even to comprehend what it is.
Our entire observable universe might occupy the equivalent of a folder on somebody else’s desktop.
Perhaps the Big Bang was simply somebody clicking “New Game”.
Perhaps the dinosaurs were an earlier build or maybe humanity is the experiment.
Perhaps the simulation has been running for billions of years, or maybe we’ve been running for just a few minutes on an alien supercomputer.
Or perhaps reality is exactly what it appears to be and we’re doing what humans have always done: staring into the enormous mystery of existence and inventing increasingly elaborate explanations because “we don’t know” is an answer our brains absolutely fucking hate.
And so, that’s where I’m leaving this entire list.
After Flat Earth, Hollow Earth, fake Moon landings, phantom centuries, Mandela Effects, Project Blue Beam and 9/11 conspiracies, we’ve finally reached a theory where I can’t confidently tell you it’s bollocks.
I can only tell you that there’s currently no convincing evidence that it’s true.
The thing is, if I’m being completely honest, there’s a part of me that finds myself buying into this theory. Not enough so that I’d claim it’s definitely true, but enough so that if I died, and then woke up in a lab somewhere having experienced the VR game “Earth and The Humans” my reaction would not be, “what the shit?” but rather, “I knew it. I fucking knew it.”
So, in light of, or in spite of, all this, tomorrow morning I’ll get up, make breakfast, work, worry about money, ride my bike and continue behaving as though physical reality exists.
DISCLAIMER
The views and opinions in this blog are my own, and do not represent the views or opinions of my former, current, or future employers, nor should they be considered advice.
If you want personalised financial advice, seek an appropriate professional. If you are in financial difficulty, seek advice via the resources below:
Hello and welcome back to Mortgage Advisor on FIRE.
Weekly Update
It’s been a couple of weeks since the last post, but there’s no ominous reason behind this. It’s just a case of there not being enough hours in the day, or enough days in the week.
Work continues to be a positive, and so much better than my previous two roles after leaving Lloyds. My new AFI Podcast venture has also been taking up a fair amount of time as we get that off the ground. As I’ve said before, it will probably be the case that updates here happen slightly less frequently than before, so thank you for sticking with me.
The AFI Podcast
Check out the AFI section of this site for links to the pod on the various platforms.
As a new podcast, getting noticed is difficult, so please help us out by sharing the links, and leaving a rating and review.
What I’m Doing
Listening: The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook: Dungeon Crawler Carl Book 3 by Matt Dinniman.
Watching: The Diplomat (Netflix).
Reading: Abaddon’s Gate (Expanse Book 3) by James S. A. Corey.
Financial Update
Assets
Premium Bonds: £500.00.
Stocks and Shares ISA: £141,458.72.
Fuck It Fund: £0.00.
Pensions: £126,976.62.
Residential Property Value: £245,790.00.
Total Assets: £514,725.34.
Debts
Residential Mortgage: £173,115.21.
Total Debts: £173,115.21.
Total Wealth
Total Wealth: £341,610.13.
As my pipeline of business at work develops, I’m hoping to start regularly investing again soon. It’s been a long, long time since I was able to regularly invest in any significant way. I’m probably still another month away from being able to do this, but things are looking up.
One thing I’m appreciating more and more is how much I’m enjoying being self-employed in the right environment. Having greater control over my working day makes a huge difference. I can organise my time, get on with helping clients, and make decisions without feeling as though I need to justify every minute. There’s still responsibility, and plenty of work to do, but I’m trusted to do it.
That feeling of being treated like a grown-up shouldn’t be remarkable, but after some of my previous experiences, it really is. Before, it often felt as though I had a constant shadow looming over me. Even when I was doing what I needed to do, there was an underlying tension, a sense that another interruption or demand for an explanation was just around the corner. It’s difficult to feel confident when you’re constantly bracing yourself.
Now, I have support when I need it and the space to work independently. I’m finding that I can put more energy into the actual job because I’m spending less of it worrying about how I’m being perceived. Financial independence is still the goal, but having more autonomy along the way makes the journey considerably more enjoyable.
We’re approaching the end of our journey through some of the world’s most extraordinary conspiracy theories, and this week we’re tackling perhaps the most controversial entry on the list.
On 11 September 2001, 19 al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked four passenger aircraft. Two were flown into the World Trade Center towers in New York, a third struck the Pentagon, and the fourth crashed in Pennsylvania after passengers attempted to regain control. Nearly 3,000 people were killed, with thousands more injured and countless lives permanently changed.
The attacks reshaped international politics, foreign policy, aviation security and the lives of millions of people. They contributed to wars, expanded surveillance powers and fundamentally changed how governments approached terrorism. There was a pre-9/11 world and a post-9/11 world.
They also, unsurprisingly, generated an extraordinary number of conspiracy theories.
Unlike Flat Earth or Hollow Earth, this isn’t something I enjoy joking about. Thousands of families lost loved ones, and the consequences are still being felt. Nevertheless, some of the claims made about 9/11 are so spectacularly flawed that they deserve examination, with the occasional application of ridicule where appropriate.
Questioning the official account is perfectly reasonable. Questioning governments is perfectly reasonable. Demanding evidence and accountability is perfectly reasonable, but questioning something and providing evidence for an alternative explanation are two very different things.
What exactly is the conspiracy theory?
That’s our first problem. There isn’t one single 9/11 conspiracy theory. I doubt there’s enough room in a single blog post to summarise even a fraction of them.
Some people believe the US government knew the attacks were coming but deliberately allowed them to happen. Others believe elements within government actively organised the attacks. Some suggest the aircraft were remotely controlled, the World Trade Center was brought down using explosives, or a missile rather than an aircraft struck the Pentagon. I’ve even seen people claiming the planes were holograms. If we could generate holograms that well, it would be incredible. Sadly, we can’t.
The theories are sometimes divided into LIHOP, meaning Let It Happen On Purpose, and MIHOP, meaning Made It Happen On Purpose. These are enormously different allegations. One suggests people with advance knowledge deliberately failed to intervene. The other suggests government insiders actually planned or carried out the attacks.
Annoyingly, discussions frequently move between them as though they’re interchangeable. One minute someone is asking why intelligence agencies failed to prevent the attacks. The next they’re suggesting explosives were secretly installed throughout the World Trade Center.
That’s quite a leap from A to B.
Why do people believe it?
The attacks were almost incomprehensible. Two enormous skyscrapers collapsed, thousands died and the world’s most powerful military appeared unable to prevent four hijacked aircraft from being used as weapons.
When something that significant happens, it’s understandable that people struggle to accept that a relatively small terrorist organisation could inflict such catastrophic damage. There’s a tendency to expect enormous events to have equally enormous causes.
Secondly, governments genuinely do lie. The United States has a history of intelligence failures, covert operations and political deception. Vietnam, Watergate and the misleading claims surrounding Iraqi weapons of mass destruction are hardly advertisements for unquestioning trust in government.
But here’s the important distinction: evidence that governments have lied about some things isn’t evidence that they’re lying about everything.
Otherwise, we can justify virtually anything. The government lied about Iraq, therefore, the Moon landing was fake. Governments conducted unethical experiments; therefore, Bigfoot is being held at Guantanamo Bay.
At some point, we need evidence connecting previous wrongdoing to the specific allegation being made.
“Jet fuel can’t melt steel beams!”
The basic argument is that jet fuel burns at temperatures below the melting point of structural steel; therefore, the fires couldn’t have caused the towers to collapse.
The first part is broadly correct. Steel melts at roughly 1,500°C depending on its composition. The problem is that the steel didn’t need to melt.
Steel loses strength as its temperature increases. Think about a blacksmith heating metal before shaping it. It doesn’t need to become a puddle before it becomes significantly easier to bend. The metal just needs to soften enough to be shaped.
NIST’s investigation identified a combination of aircraft impact damage, dislodged fireproofing and extensive fires. The impacts damaged structural columns and knocked fire-resistant insulation from steel components. Fires then heated the exposed steel, floors sagged, and exterior columns were pulled inward until the structures could no longer support the loads above them.
NIST estimated some fires reached approximately 1,000°C. At those sorts of temperatures, unprotected structural steel can lose a substantial proportion of its strength.
So “jet fuel can’t melt steel beams” attacks an explanation nobody actually needs. It’s like arguing chocolate can’t become soft because it hasn’t turned into liquid. If you put a chocolate bar in your pocket for a while, it will get pretty soft without turning completely into a liquid.
Controlled demolition?
This is probably the most visually compelling argument. Watch footage of the towers collapsing, and it’s easy to understand why someone might compare them to controlled demolitions. They’re enormous buildings; they collapse rapidly, and huge clouds of dust engulf the surrounding streets.
But something looking similar doesn’t establish that the same mechanism caused it.
Controlled demolition requires carefully planned destruction of structural supports. Engineers need access to the building, knowledge of its structure, preparation of components and carefully positioned explosives.
The towers had suffered catastrophic aircraft impacts followed by extensive fires. NIST found that the collapses began in the damaged impact and fire zones, with the upper sections subsequently descending onto the structures below. Investigators found no corroborating evidence that explosives initiated the collapses.
Once those upper sections began moving, enormous gravitational energy was released onto the structure beneath them.
Buildings aren’t indestructible simply because they’re large. Structural engineering relies upon forces being distributed through interconnected components. Damage enough components, weaken others through heat and eventually the remaining structure may become unable to carry the loads imposed upon it.
The fact the towers survived the initial impacts doesn’t mean they were guaranteed to survive indefinitely. Considering the damage, the time they remained standing was critically important because it allowed many people to escape. Had the towers collapsed immediately after impact, the death toll would have been much, much worse.
“What about the explosions?”
People reported hearing explosions during the attacks and collapses. That’s true and eyewitness testimony deserves to be treated seriously.
But the word explosion describes an event or sound. It doesn’t automatically identify its cause.
A catastrophic building fire and structural collapse can produce extraordinarily loud noises from rupturing equipment, failing structural components and falling debris. Conspiracy videos also highlight bursts of dust emerging from windows during collapse, describing them as explosive charges. NIST explained these as air and debris being forced outward as the descending structure compressed the floors below. It’s a bit like if you were to sit on an inflated balloon. If you apply enough pressure, the balloon will burst from the sides.
Does that mean every sound heard that day can be identified beyond doubt? Obviously not. With the absolute chaos of that day there will have been countless unidentified noises.
But an unexplained noise isn’t automatically a bomb.
Building 7: The conspiracy theorist’s favourite skyscraper
Now we arrive at probably the strongest-looking argument in the entire 9/11 conspiracy movement.
World Trade Center Building 7 wasn’t struck by an aircraft. It was a 47-storey building near the main complex and collapsed at approximately 5:20pm.
Footage looks dramatic and the collapse is frequently compared to controlled demolition. However, Building 7 had been damaged by debris from the collapse of the North Tower and burned for hours. Damage to water infrastructure also compromised its sprinkler systems.
NIST concluded that uncontrolled fires caused thermal expansion of structural components, ultimately triggering failure around a critical column and initiating progressive collapse.
As steel heats, it expands. That expansion can place enormous forces on structural connections. According to NIST’s analysis, thermal expansion caused a critical connection to fail, setting off a chain of structural failures. The internal structure was already failing before the exterior visibly descended.
There is also the famous claim that Building 7 experienced free fall. Interestingly, NIST acknowledged a period of free-fall acceleration during part of the visible collapse. Its explanation was that internal failures had already removed support from that portion of the exterior before this phase.
Critics dispute aspects of the modelling, and technical disagreement is legitimate. But disagreement with a structural model isn’t evidence that explosives were planted.
Building 7’s collapse was unusual. It was the first known example of a tall building collapsing primarily because of uncontrolled fires.
But unusual doesn’t mean impossible, and unprecedented doesn’t mean conspiratorial.
There is a first time for everything, including engineering failures.
“The Pentagon wasn’t hit by a plane!”
Another theory claims the Pentagon was struck by a missile rather than American Airlines Flight 77. Supporters often point to photographs and argue the visible damage was too small for a Boeing 757.
The problem is that an aircraft travelling at high speed doesn’t behave like a cartoon cut-out. It doesn’t punch a perfectly recognisable aeroplane-shaped hole into a building, complete with neat outlines for the wings and tail. Different components fragment, deform and penetrate structures differently.
More importantly, Flight 77 was a real aircraft carrying real passengers and crew. Evidence included radar information, eyewitness accounts, physical evidence and identification of victims.
Replace that aircraft with a missile and suddenly you need to explain what happened to the plane and its passengers, how records and physical evidence were falsified, who organised it and why anyone would disappear an actual passenger aircraft only to use a missile instead.
The conspiracy doesn’t simplify the event. It makes it vastly more complicated.
For this specific point, I also know someone who witnessed the aircraft flying overhead towards the Pentagon. I’ll take their account over claims that there was secretly a missile involved.
What about Flight 93?
United Airlines Flight 93 crashed in Pennsylvania after passengers attempted to regain control. Some theories claim it was shot down, while others suggest an aircraft never crashed there at all.
The evidence includes recovered wreckage, human remains, flight-recorder information, radar records and investigation of the crash site. The cockpit voice recording also provided evidence of the struggle aboard.
Having learned about the other attacks, passengers attempted to prevent their own aircraft being used as another weapon. There is no credible evidence establishing that Flight 93 was shot down.
Once again, the alternative theory requires us to discard substantial evidence while creating even more questions.
Out of all the 9/11 conspiracy theories, this is probably the most likely, but being the most likely does not make it likely. It’s just the least bad theory. It is possible that during the struggle to take back the aircraft, the US military shot the plane down. In the context of what had already happened that day, it could realistically have been an option. Do I think it actually happened this way? No. Once again, too many people would have to know and be involved.
The pilot of the fighter jet wouldn’t be the only one to know. There would be the ground crew inspecting the plane on its return to base and noting the missing missile. There would be the various after-action reports. By this point, we’re already talking about dozens of people knowing that a) a fighter jet was sent to intercept a hijacked plane b) that hijacked place crashed, and c) the fighter jet returned to base having used some of its weapons.
In this scenario, 2+2 would reasonably equal 4.
“So, why didn’t the military stop the planes?”
This is a much more reasonable question.
How could four hijacked aircraft operate within American airspace without the world’s most powerful military stopping them?
The aviation security and air-defence systems of 2001 weren’t designed around hijackers deliberately crashing passenger aircraft into buildings. Previous hijackings generally involved demands, negotiations and attempts to divert aircraft.
The 9/11 Commission documented confusion, communication failures, inaccurate information and delays involving the FAA and military. In some cases, military personnel were responding to incorrect information about aircraft locations or hijacking status.
That’s a legitimate reason to demand accountability.
But incompetence, poor communication and institutional failures aren’t automatically evidence of deliberate participation.
Anyone who has worked in a large organisation knows multiple departments can fail spectacularly to communicate while supposedly working towards the same objective. Now imagine an unprecedented situation involving incomplete information where decisions have to be made in minutes.
Sometimes the explanation really is that people didn’t know what the hell they were doing.
That isn’t reassuring, but it is entirely plausible.
Also, in the context of the US, the points of departure for the hijacked planes and their targets were fairly close together. The two planes that struck the towers had been in the air for less than an hour before impact. The time between being hijacked, and for the authorities to notice the hijacking, and then impact, was not that long.
“There was suspicious trading before the attacks!”
Now we’re getting into territory particularly relevant to a financial blog.
There were claims that investors bought unusually large numbers of put options in airline companies before 9/11. Because puts can increase in value when shares fall, advance knowledge of an attack on the airline industry could theoretically have generated enormous profits.
That’s absolutely worth investigating.
And it was.
The Securities and Exchange Commission examined more than 9.5 million securities transactions from the weeks preceding the attacks. Investigators examined airlines, other companies, derivatives and market indices.
They found unusual activity, but investigated trades had explanations unrelated to advance knowledge. Some were connected to institutional strategies, while others followed investment recommendations. The SEC reported finding no evidence that anyone traded using advance knowledge of the attacks.
This illustrates an important point. An anomaly can justify investigation without proving the allegation.
If a company’s shares collapse tomorrow, somebody somewhere will probably have positioned themselves profitably beforehand. That doesn’t automatically mean they knew what was coming.
“The government needed an excuse to invade Iraq!”
There are entirely legitimate criticisms of American foreign policy after 9/11. Afghanistan was invaded in 2001 and Iraq in 2003, with claims about Iraqi weapons of mass destruction subsequently discredited.
But there’s a logical problem with treating the consequences of an event as proof someone caused it.
Benefiting from something doesn’t mean you organised it.
Governments can exploit crises they didn’t create. Politicians can use public fear to advance policies they already favoured. Businesses can profit from disasters without causing them.
The fact 9/11 was subsequently used to justify policies and military action doesn’t establish that the attacks were orchestrated to produce those outcomes. That requires evidence of planning and involvement.
We don’t need to invent an enormous conspiracy about 9/11 to criticise the Iraq War.
“But governments have considered false-flag operations!”
The concept of a false-flag operation is real. One frequently cited example is Operation Northwoods, a proposed US military plan from 1962 involving deceptive incidents intended to create support for action against Cuba.
The proposals were not implemented, but their existence demonstrates that officials have contemplated deeply unethical schemes.
That’s a legitimate historical observation.
It doesn’t demonstrate that an entirely different operation occurred nearly forty years later.
If I discover someone once considered robbing a bank, I haven’t proved they robbed every bank in the country.
Historical precedent can demonstrate that something is conceivable, but it cannot demonstrate that it happened.
For that, we need evidence specific to the event.
What about the official investigations?
The 9/11 Commission investigated the attacks and failures that allowed them to occur. Its findings included serious criticism of intelligence sharing, aviation security, preparedness and government response. NIST separately investigated the structural failures of the World Trade Center buildings.
Neither should be treated as sacred texts beyond criticism. It’s entirely reasonable to scrutinise their methods, assumptions and conclusions.
But rejecting an investigation doesn’t automatically establish your alternative.
It’s also worth recognising that some deeply uncomfortable findings about government failures came from official investigations themselves. Institutional mistakes weren’t universally denied or hidden.
The question is whether those failures demonstrate incompetence and inadequate preparation or deliberate participation in mass murder.
Those are fundamentally different conclusions.
Why I think this conspiracy is particularly damaging
With something like Hollow Earth, the consequences of believing it are fairly limited. If someone thinks there are dinosaurs living beneath Antarctica, they’re probably not doing much harm beyond making themselves look a bit daft.
9/11 is different.
Real people died in horrific circumstances. Families have spent decades living with the consequences, while survivors and emergency responders have suffered lasting physical and psychological effects.
That doesn’t put 9/11 beyond questioning. Serious scrutiny of government conduct, intelligence failures and the consequences of the attacks is important.
But there’s a responsibility to distinguish legitimate investigation from speculation presented as fact.
If we’re spending all our time arguing about whether jet fuel can melt steel beams, we’re not necessarily discussing the more important questions about intelligence failures, foreign policy, civil liberties and government accountability.
And perhaps that’s the biggest problem with this particular conspiracy theory.
“I don’t understand how this happened” is not the same thing as “therefore the government did it.”
Questions are the beginning of an investigation, not the conclusion.
Governments aren’t omnipotent. Intelligence agencies make mistakes. Security systems have weaknesses. People with relatively limited resources can cause catastrophic harm.
That’s arguably more frightening than believing someone secretly controls everything.
The 9/11 attacks were an extraordinary tragedy. They exposed serious weaknesses in American security and were followed by political and military decisions that deserve continued scrutiny.
None of that requires us to believe the attacks were secretly orchestrated by the American government.
You can distrust politicians, criticise intelligence agencies, oppose wars and demand accountability without believing that every catastrophe was secretly planned.
In fact, those criticisms become considerably stronger when they’re based on evidence rather than speculation.
The people demanding that we question everything sometimes seem remarkably reluctant to question their own conclusions.
Question everything. Including the damned conspiracy theory.
DISCLAIMER
The views and opinions in this blog are my own, and do not represent the views or opinions of my former, current, or future employers, nor should they be considered advice.
If you want personalised financial advice, seek an appropriate professional. If you are in financial difficulty, seek advice via the resources below: