
Hello and welcome back to Mortgage Advisor on FIRE.
Weekly Update
A bit of a shorter post this week due to the fact that I generally need about 36 hours per day to get everything done.
Sadly, I think my bike, which I call The Roci (short for Rocinante from Don Quixote and The Expanse), is knackered. I normally cycle a couple of hundred kilometres each week, so it does take some hammer. I had the bike serviced just a couple of weeks ago, and since then it’s been making strange sounds and I can feel some vibrations and grinding in the bike. At the weekend, Oana and I went for a ride and as I hit a small hill, it was like a switch was flipped and the bike felt as though the brakes were being constantly applied.
We couldn’t diagnose the exact issue, and spent a fair amount of time checking the brakes but there was no obvious issue. So it looks like my Roci is going back in for more work.
This Week on The AFI Podcast
Check out the AFI section of this site for links to the pod on the various platforms.
See below for a clip from a recent episode.
As a new podcast, getting noticed is difficult, so please help us out by sharing the links, and leaving a rating and review.
What I’m Doing
Listening: Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman.
Watching: Widow’s Bay (Netflix).
Reading: Abaddon’s Gate (Expanse Book 3) by James S. A. Corey.
Financial Update
Assets
Premium Bonds: £250.00.
Stocks and Shares ISA: £140,641.31.
Fuck It Fund: £0.00.
Pensions: £128,112.51.
Residential Property Value: £245,790.00.
Total Assets: £514,793.82.
Debts
Residential Mortgage: £173,115.21.
Total Debts: £173,115.21.
Total Wealth
Total Wealth: £341,678.61.
Top Ten Funniest/Most Crazy Conspiracy Theories
10. Flat Earth (Part 355)
9. Hollow Earth (Part 356)
8. The Mandela Effect (Part 357)
7. Titanic Was Swapped With Olympic (Part 358)
6. The Phantom Time Hypothesis: What If Someone Just Made Up 300 Years? (Part 359)
5. The Moon Landing Was Faked (Part 360)
4. Project Blue Beam: When Faking the Moon Landing Just Isn’t Ambitious Enough (Part 361)
3. Climate Change Isn’t Real: The weather has entered the chat…
We’ve reached another entry in my completely unordered tour through the world’s most batshit conspiracy theories. And this one is different.
Flat Earth is funny. Hollow Earth is brilliant, although I remain disappointed there aren’t dinosaurs beneath Doncaster. Project Blue Beam gives us Giant Sky Jesus and fake aliens.
Climate change denial has real consequences. Decisions made today affect people decades from now. That doesn’t mean we can’t have some fun with the arguments. Because fuck me… Some of the arguments…
There are legitimate debates about climate change: how quickly particular effects will occur, which policies work, what governments should spend, and how we balance environmental objectives against energy security and living standards. Science doesn’t magically answer every political question.
But that’s different from saying climate change isn’t happening, humans have nothing to do with it, or scientists know it’s fake but are all lying.
That last one takes us properly into conspiracy territory.
First, is the planet actually warming?
Yes. This doesn’t rest on one thermometer outside NASA. Temperature records show long-term warming, supported by ocean temperatures, melting glaciers and ice sheets, rising sea levels and other measurements.
The evidence doesn’t come from one organisation or country either. Which creates an immediate problem for the conspiracy: who is fabricating it? NASA? Fine. What about everyone else?
“But the climate has always changed!”
Correct. Congratulations, you’ve accidentally discovered climate science.
Earth has experienced ice ages and warmer periods. Its orbit changes. Solar activity varies. Volcanoes and ocean circulation affect climate. Nobody thinks Earth’s temperature remained perfectly constant until Ford built the Model-T. We know about past climate change largely because climate scientists study it.
The questions are why it’s changing now, how quickly, and what’s driving it.
Saying today’s change must be natural because climate changed before is like saying people have died naturally for thousands of years, therefore murder doesn’t exist. Natural causes don’t eliminate other causes.
It’s CO₂, not Voldemort
Earth receives energy from the Sun and radiates energy towards space. Greenhouse gases absorb and re-emit some infrared radiation. Adding more changes that energy balance.
We’ve known about carbon dioxide’s heat-trapping properties since the nineteenth century. This wasn’t invented by Greta Thunberg’s marketing department in 2018. Burning fossil fuels has substantially increased atmospheric CO₂, and that increase matters.
“But CO₂ is only a tiny percentage of the atmosphere!”
It is. So what? You don’t put cyanide in your tea, calculate that it’s a tiny percentage of the drink and crack on. A substance’s effect depends on its properties, not whether it occupies an impressively large proportion of the mixture.
Then there’s “it’s only a couple of degrees.” Our own bodies demonstrate why small temperature changes can matter. That doesn’t make global temperature and body temperature equivalent; they’re different systems. But dismissing a change because the number sounds small is idiotic. Ecosystems, agriculture and ice sheets operate within particular conditions. Earth doesn’t need to become Venus for a few degrees to be a very fucking big deal.
“It was cold yesterday”
This is the argument that makes climate scientists stare into the middle distance while I facepalm hard enough to leave a permanent handprint.
Weather describes short-term conditions in a particular place. Climate describes patterns over longer periods and larger areas. Global warming doesn’t mean Britain is contractually prohibited from having a cold day.
Snow in Sheffield doesn’t disprove decades of planetary warming. Equally, one hot afternoon doesn’t prove it. Long-term patterns matter more than whether you needed a coat this morning. There are going to be short-term fluctuations. It’s the big picture that matters.
Then someone inevitably summons 1976. Mention a heatwave and a man materialises beside a paddling pool to tell you summers used to be hot too.
1976 was hot. Nobody is debating it. Climate change doesn’t mean hot weather never happened before; it changes the background against which weather occurs. You can roll a six with an ordinary die. Loading it makes sixes more common. An earlier six doesn’t prove the die hasn’t changed.
“They changed the name!”
This is usually delivered as though someone has uncovered Watergate.
Global warming means the long-term rise in Earth’s average surface temperature. Climate change includes that warming and wider changes to rainfall, ice, sea level and other parts of the climate system. Both terms are useful.
It’s not a rebrand to conceal the awkward fact that winter still exists.
“Scientists predicted an ice age!”
Some scientists investigated cooling, and newspapers ran stories about it. But the claim that a scientific consensus predicted an imminent ice age in the 1970s is false. Reviews of the literature found papers anticipating warming substantially outnumbered those anticipating cooling.
Our knowledge has also improved. Better observations, longer datasets and better computers help. Science changing with evidence is the point of science. Refusing today’s findings because researchers knew less fifty years ago is like refusing modern cancer treatment because doctors understood cancer less well in 1920.
“Climate models aren’t perfect”
Correct. Nobody serious claims otherwise.
Models simplify complicated systems and contain uncertainties. Weather forecasts aren’t perfect either, but if torrential rain is predicted, I’m probably not organising a picnic because the Met Office isn’t omniscient.
The questions are whether models are useful, their assumptions reasonable, and their results consistent with observations.
Uncertainty isn’t ignorance. If a doctor is uncertain how quickly a disease will progress, you don’t conclude: “Excellent. Therefore I don’t have it.”
“Scientists just want research grants”
How many scientists? In how many countries, universities and institutions? Using how many independent measurements?
And why wouldn’t convincingly disproving human-caused warming be a spectacular scientific achievement? Produce robust evidence overturning one of the biggest scientific conclusions of the modern era and you’d be fucking famous.
The conspiracy requires researchers to crave advancement enough to fake findings, but ignore the rewards of genuinely overturning them. Interesting incentive structure.
Then there’s the scale. Universities, meteorological agencies, satellite programmes and oceanographic institutes across the world would need to cooperate. Countries that can’t agree on borders, wars or trade have apparently achieved flawless coordination over falsifying atmospheric physics.
Where are the documents? The convincing alternative measurements? The mechanism coordinating the fraud?
Apparently humanity finally achieved global cooperation, and used it to fake the weather.
“But scientists disagree!”
They do: about regional effects, feedbacks, climate sensitivity and consequences. That doesn’t create an equally divided field over whether human greenhouse-gas emissions warm the planet.
Dissent matters. Show the evidence, publish it and let others test it. But if 99 engineers say a bridge is unsafe and one disagrees, that doesn’t automatically create a 50/50 debate. This is a problem with our society in so many ways. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but it doesn’t mean all opinions are equally valid. Expertise, knowledge, experience, and education all matter.
Consensus isn’t proof by itself. Evidence matters. However, dismissing compatible findings from thousands of specialists requires more than “my uncle reckons winters were colder when he was a lad.”
“They’re manipulating temperature records!”
Weather stations move. Instruments and observation times change. Scientists account for known measurement problems. Describe this as “THEY ALTER THE RAW DATA” and it sounds sinister. It’s measurement science.
If I weigh myself wearing a backpack full of bricks and account for its weight, I haven’t joined the New World Order.
Warming also appears across independent observations of oceans, ice and the atmosphere. Faking one dataset wouldn’t explain the rest.
Follow the money. All of it.
Energy involves enormous financial interests. Scrutinise fossil-fuel companies, renewables, governments, researchers and campaigners. Excellent.
But “money exists” doesn’t establish that a scientific claim is false. Conflicts of interest demand transparency and independent evidence, not automatically declaring whoever receives funding you dislike a liar.
“It’s all about control”
Taxes, banned cars, insects for dinner, global government. Pick your favourite.
You can oppose a carbon tax while accepting that carbon dioxide obeys physics. You can consider an environmental policy expensive, ineffective or authoritarian without denying the problem it supposedly addresses.
Otherwise you’re reasoning backwards: “I dislike the solution, therefore the problem can’t be real.” I dislike replacing a leaking toilet. That doesn’t make the bathroom floor dry.
Accepting climate science doesn’t require swallowing every catastrophic headline either. Politicians, campaigners and newspapers exaggerate. Particular predictions can be wrong. None of that automatically overturns the underlying evidence.
There’s space between “it’s all a scam” and “civilisation ends next Thursday at 2:15pm.” Science lives there.
And if you can secretly manipulate scientific institutions worldwide, why choose such a slow route to domination? Surely you don’t need fifty years to persuade people to buy heat pumps.
Scepticism is good. Question scientists, politicians and corporations. But apply the standards consistently. Don’t demand impossible certainty from evidence you dislike while accepting a Facebook meme because it agrees with you.
DISCLAIMER
The views and opinions in this blog are my own, and do not represent the views or opinions of my former, current, or future employers, nor should they be considered advice.
If you want personalised financial advice, seek an appropriate professional. If you are in financial difficulty, seek advice via the resources below:
Biolink
You can now find all my social media pages by checking out my Biolink:
bio.link/davidscothern.
BBC weather says it’s going to rain today, but I’m looking out of my window right now, and seeing blue sky. Checkmate, climate scientists!